6 Unbelievable Unsolved Crimes to Intrigue Your Inner Investigator

illustrated evidence box

The viral popularity of true crime podcasts and documentaries like Serial and Making a Murderer has sparked the interest of millions across the globe. But once one of our trusty true crime series concludes or hits the off-season lull, the newfound reality of life as “armchair detectives” leaves us hungry for more!

We’re all too familiar with the unanswered questions surrounding some of our country’s most notorious unsolved crimes: Who is the Zodiac Killer? What happened to JonBenet Ramsey? Who killed Tupac and Biggie? Is O.J. actually innocent?

Let’s face it – it might be a while before the next Steven Avery or Adnan Syed works his or her way into the limelight. But there are a number of equally-intriguing cases that haven’t received as much press. In the meantime, let these six suspenseful unsolved crimes put your inner investigator to work.

6 Unsolved crimes that will leave you baffled

1. The disappearance of Maura Murray

If you’re a true internet sleuth, you may have stumbled across this case already. Maura Murray was 21 on February 9, 2004 when she crashed her car into a snow bank after losing control on a sharp turn of a New Hampshire highway. A passing school bus driver stopped to help, asking the young nursing student if he could call the police for her. She said she’d already called them using her cell phone.

Knowing the cell service in that area was non-existent, the bus driver retreated to his home to call for help. By the time law enforcement showed up just minutes later, Murray had vanished. Her odd behavior leading up to the night of the crash has left many baffled, and theories as to whether Murray left willingly or was met with foul play have circulated for more than 12 years. To this day, she’s never been seen or heard from.

You can learn more about the details of Maura Murray’s case here.

2. The death of Elisa Lam

If you’re looking for a truly bizarre case — one about which theories have taken every possible turn imaginable — then you may find your inner investigator intrigued by the disappearance and death of Elisa Lam. The 21-year-old Canadian native was embarking on a solo trip around California when she wound up staying at a notorious hotel on LA’s Skid Row.

It was in elevator surveillance footage of that hotel — four eerie and peculiar minutes of grainy video — that Lam was last seen in the early hours of February 1, 2013. She was officially declared missing a few days later and her body was found in one of the hotel’s rooftop water tanks three weeks after she vanished. The LAPD suspected foul play before ruling her cause of death as “undetermined” and later shifting the official ruling to “accidental.” Internet sleuths still have sizable doubts.

Interestingly enough, Elisa Lam’s case served as the inspiration for the fifth season of American Horror Story, subtitled, “Hotel.” You can learn more about the details of the case here.

3. The disappearance of Nicholas Barclay

The aftermath of Nicholas Barclay’s disappearance has transformed this case into one of the strangest and most confounding missing person cases of all time. The 13-year-old vanished after playing basketball with friends in his hometown of San Antonio, Texas in 1994. After exhaustive searches that turned up empty, his family held out hope.

Three years later, the Barclay family received word that he was in police custody in Spain, armed with a harrowing story of kidnapping, torture and abuse. They welcomed the boy back into their Texas home with open arms. But much to everyone’s surprise, a few months later a private investigator discovered that he was not, in fact, the long-lost 16-year-old Barclay, but a 23-year-old French con artist named Frederic Bourdin.

The real Nicholas Barclay has still not been found. You can learn more about his case here.

4. The murder of Amber Hagerman

We’ve become so familiar with the use of the term “Amber Alert” in modern newscasts that it can be alarmingly easy to forget it was inspired by a true life missing person’s case.

Amber Hagerman disappeared when she was nine years old as she rode her bicycle through a local grocery store parking lot on January 13, 1996. A blue truck was reportedly seen fleeing the scene. Despite days of national attention and constant law enforcement efforts, her body was later discovered just miles from the grocery store. More than 20 years and thousands of tips later, her killer remains to be identified.

You can learn more about the details of Amber Hagerman’s case here.

5. The disappearance of Adam Hecht

Adam Hecht was the 24-year-old son of a Hollywood producer and a tennis instructor when he went missing in June of 1989. In January of that same year, Hecht befriended a homeless man named Tony while on a breakfast outing with his brother. Just weeks later, he invited Tony to move in with him.

Hecht’s family had remarked that his behavior began to rapidly change after spending time with his new roommate, the two of them spending an increasing amount of time near LA’s Skid Row. This made it even more puzzling when Hecht abruptly disappeared while Tony remained living in his home, alleging he had no idea what happened to his friend and roommate. Just a few days later, Hecht’s mother visited the home and was met by Tony’s strange behavior, claiming he was her son.

Hecht’s car was found in Beverly Hills one month after he vanished with keys in the ignition, wallet on the front seat and an accumulation of parking tickets on the windshield. The family immediately suspected foul play at the hand of Tony, but authorities determined he wasn’t involved.

Adam Hecht has still never been seen or heard from. You can learn more about his case here.

6. The murder of Suzanne Jovin

Suzanne Jovin was 21 years old on December 21, 1998. She left the Yale University Police substation one night after dropping off keys to a university car she had borrowed. Half an hour later, she was found fatally wounded on a street corner just two miles away.

Over the years, several theories have emerged including authorities suspecting one of Jovin’s former professors and independent investigators suspecting an attempted random kidnapping gone wrong. But none of these have lasted the test of time as strongly as the notion that Jovin may have been murdered by a mentally disturbed Yale architecture student.

The young student’s face closely resembled a police sketch from an eyewitness account of a man running wildly down a nearby street around the time of the murder. The same man showed up at a former classmate’s doorstep in 2011, declaring that he’d become obsessed with Jovin’s murder. He died of an apparent suicide in 2012, and his involvement has not been investigated further by the police.

You can learn more details about the Suzanne Jovin cold case here.

Put your inner investigator to work

Each of these unsolved crimes is as puzzling as the next, which is why their answers have continued to evade the authorities investigating them. You can join the ranks of web sleuths across the globe in the efforts to discover the next big break in one of these cases.

If you’re itching to learn more about investigative techniques and specialized tactics to crack notorious cold cases, you might want to consider sniffing out the clues professionally. Learn more about investigative careers in our article: Private Investigator vs. Police Detective: Making the Case.


About the author

Jess Scherman

Jess is a Content Specialist at Collegis Education. She researches and writes articles on behalf of Rasmussen University to help empower students to achieve their career dreams through higher education.


Related Content

Related Content

This piece of ad content was created by Rasmussen University to support its educational programs. Rasmussen University may not prepare students for all positions featured within this content. Please visit www.rasmussen.edu/degrees for a list of programs offered. External links provided on rasmussen.edu are for reference only. Rasmussen University does not guarantee, approve, control, or specifically endorse the information or products available on websites linked to, and is not endorsed by website owners, authors and/or organizations referenced. Rasmussen University is accredited by the Higher Learning Commission, an institutional accreditation agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education.

logo-accreditation-acen logo-accreditation-ccne chart-credential-laddering-associates-bachelors-masters 0 Credits 90 Credits 180 Credits 48 Credits Start Here HIGH SCHOOL GRADS Start Here TRANSFER STUDENTS Start Here SECOND DEGREE PURSUERS End Here ASSOCIATE'S DEGREE Start Here MASTER'S DEGREE PURSUERS End Here BACHELOR'S DEGREE End Here MASTER'S DEGREE chart-credential-laddering-associates-bachelors 0 Credits Start Here HIGH SCHOOL GRADS Start Here TRANSFER STUDENTS 90 Credits Start Here SECOND DEGREE PURSUERS End Here ASSOCIATE'S DEGREE 180 Credits End Here BACHELOR'S DEGREE chart-credential-laddering-msn chart-credential-laddering-nursing-programs chart-credential-laddering-post-grad-np chart-credential-laddering-nursing DNP MSN RN to BSN LPN to RN Bridge Accelerated BSN Professional Nursing ADN Practical Nursing Diploma Pre-Licensure Post-Licensure icon-colored-outline-bank icon-colored-outline-certificate icon-colored-outline-circle-dollar-sign icon-colored-outline-folder-search icon-colored-outline-hand-heart icon-colored-outline-head-blocks icon-colored-outline-head-cog icon-colored-outline-head-heart icon-colored-outline-health-plus-leaves icon-colored-outline-hospital icon-colored-outline-lifelong-learning icon-colored-outline-light-bulb-analytics icon-colored-outline-location-pin icon-colored-outline-magnifying-glass icon-colored-outline-monitor-healthcare icon-colored-outline-monitor-paper-search icon-colored-outline-nurse-rays icon-colored-outline-padlock-shield icon-colored-outline-person-presenter-screen icon-colored-outline-scales ras-logo-flame ras-logo-horizontal ras-logo-stacked icon-colored-advance icon-colored-arrows-cross-curve icon-colored-briefcase-star icon-colored-build icon-colored-bulb-analytics icon-colored-certificate icon-colored-continual-development icon-colored-duo-chatbox icon-colored-folder-mortarboard icon-colored-forward-ribbon icon-colored-gears-clock icon-colored-globe-pen icon-colored-growth icon-colored-hand-bubble icon-colored-hand-stars icon-colored-hands-gear icon-colored-head-blocks icon-colored-head-cog icon-colored-health-plus-leaves icon-colored-hospital-building icon-colored-laptop-cbe-skyscraper icon-colored-laptop-checkmark icon-colored-laptop-webpage icon-colored-location-map icon-colored-location-pin icon-colored-monitor-paper-scan icon-colored-mortarboard-dollar icon-colored-national icon-colored-people-chat-bubbles icon-colored-person-cheer-star icon-colored-person-laptop-checkboxes icon-colored-person-screen-instructor icon-colored-person-whiteboard icon-colored-phone-chatbox icon-colored-police-light icon-colored-prep icon-colored-presenter icon-colored-regional icon-colored-save-time icon-colored-shirt-hat icon-colored-skyscraper icon-colored-state icon-colored-student-centered icon-colored-support icon-colored-world-experience icon-triangle-arrow-up-plant icon-triangle-calendar-pencil icon-triangle-clock-rotating-arrows icon-triangle-display-gears icon-triangle-hand-right-speech-bubble icon-triangle-laptop-coding-brackets icon-triangle-mortarboard icon-triangle-paper-ribbon icon-triangle-person-cheer-star icon-triangle-person-juggle icon-triangle-triple-people-chat-bubble icon-modality-campus icon-modality-field icon-modality-online icon-modality-residential icon-arrow icon-bank icon-camera icon-filter icon-general-chart icon-general-connect icon-general-degree icon-general-discuss icon-general-email icon-general-find icon-general-hat icon-general-heart icon-general-laptop-building icon-general-laptop icon-general-leader icon-general-map icon-general-money icon-general-paperwork icon-general-people icon-general-phone icon-general-speak-out icon-head-heart icon-info-circle icon-mail-forward icon-mglass icon-play-solid icon-quote-mark-left icon-quote-mark-right icon-scales icon-share-square-o icon-simple-chat icon-simple-desktop icon-simple-find icon-simple-hamburger icon-simple-phone icon-spinner icon-tag icon-testimonial-quotes icon-util-checkbox-white icon-util-checkbox icon-util-checked-white icon-util-checked icon-util-chevron-down icon-util-chevron-left icon-util-chevron-right icon-util-chevron-up icon-util-circle-arrow-down icon-util-circle-dot icon-util-language-switch icon-util-loading icon-util-open-window-link icon-util-pdf-link icon-util-refresh icon-util-x rebrand-arrows icon-social-facebook-colored icon-social-facebook-square-colored icon-social-facebook-square icon-social-facebook icon-social-google-plus-square icon-social-google-plus icon-social-instagram-colored icon-social-instagram icon-social-linkedin-square-colored icon-social-linkedin-square icon-social-linkedin icon-social-pinterest-p-colored icon-social-pinterest-p icon-social-twitter-colored icon-social-twitter-square icon-social-twitter icon-social-youtube-play-colored icon-social-youtube-play graduate-cap-star-coin hand-coin hand-heart nurse-stethoscope-rays card-send-smile person-yoga-pose suitcase-star